What 18th Century Pirates Can Teach Us About Management
We’ve written four books about business management, the latest being The Pocket Small Business Owner’s Guide to Business Plans. This year our novel Treasure in the Moonlight was released, a suspenseful adventure blending a contemporary treasure hunt with 18th century pirate lore.
While researching the novel, we discovered that pirate captains, just like modern-day CEOs, employed time-tested management techniques that made them successful. The buccaneers defined success as capturing more treasure than competitors (maximizing ROI), building a cohesive, well-trained crew (maximizing productivity) and of course avoiding being captured by the Royal Navy and hanged (voted out by the Board of Directors).
One of the reason pirate captains are underrated as managers is that they didn’t record their management principles on paper because their lives were often cut short. Captain Edward Teach, aka Blackbeard, for example was reputed to be working on his own business motivational book tentatively titled, “Who Moved My Doubloons?” but tragically before he could finish it he got his head cut off during a battle aboard ship.
View the Crew as Stakeholders
The CEO of a pirate ship, the Captain, was granted broad powers during battle situations, but on day-to-day matters regarding the operation of the ship, was expected to follow the wishes of the majority of the crew. According to the book General History of the Pirates, on famous pirate Bartholomew “Black Bart” Roberts’ ship, “Every man has a vote in affairs of moment; has equal title to the fresh provisions, or strong liquors, at any time seized…”
The captain was elected by the crew and could be removed if they weren’t satisfied with his performance. Every crew member was deemed to have a stake in the success of the voyage.
Before the voyage a code of conduct for the enterprise was drawn up during a council made up of the pirates, and each crewmember was bound to obey it. This system encouraged team spirit and loyalty among the crewmembers.
Imagine it’s your first day at a corporate job and the CEO asks your opinion of the company’s code of conduct. You’d probably faint.
Make Sure Compensation for the Voyage is Fair and Spelled Out
Pirate ship compensation was heavily incentive-based. “No prey, no pay,” the system was called.
On one ship, as quoted in the book Under the Black Flag, the formula was: “The captain and quartermaster to receive two shares of a prize; the master, boatswain, and gunner, one share and a half, and other officers one and a quarter.” Each crewmember received a specified share as well. Everyone knew what share they would earn. Since these compensation formulas were not secret, resentment of them by the crew was minimized. No top-secret “salary grades” for the brethren of the coast.
Beware Competitors Sailing Under False Colors
When approaching another ship at sea, pirate captains would often fly the flag of a friendly nation rather than their signature pirate flag. The unsuspecting ship would let them approach, and the pirates would attack. We’ve seen this in business when a company seeks a joint venture arrangement but really just wants to pirate your customers or your intellectual property. Savvy captains of the era would not trust these false colors and kept their crew on alert for a possible battle whenever they encountered an unknown vessel.
Make Sure Independent Contractors Don’t Exceed Their Authority
Letters of Marque were licenses issued by Royal Authority, and sometimes by authority of the Colonial governors. These allowed a privately owned ship to hunt down and plunder the ships of enemy nations without any consequences or punishment. These ships were referred to as privateers, not pirates. The Letters of Marque spelled out what these privateers were allowed to do, and what actions were out-of-bounds.
Having privateers effectively gave a nation additional global naval power, in other words, expanded their distribution channels.
The danger for the official issuing the Letters was that their “independent contractors” would lose their moral compass and attack the wrong ship, which could be interpreted as an act of war by the country that ship was from.
This problem often occurred because the official couldn’t possibly supervise an independent contractor that was sailing on the other side of the world.
Take Care of Crew Members Who Suffer on the Job Injuries
Pirates had their own early form of health insurance, and would generously provide for members of their crew who sustained injuries. One ship’s policy was very specific about how much each disability was worth, as quoted in Under the Black Flag: “600 pieces of eight for losing your right arm, left leg 400 pieces of eight, loss of finger 100 pieces of eight.”
A great thing about the pirate private health insurance program (PPHI) was that it was available from the moment the ship sailed, not just during a vague “open enrollment period.” The pirate captains were careful to keep their promise to the crew. As one captain said, “If ye likes yer plan, ye can keeps yer plan.” Captains who broke that promise might find themselves marooned.
Brian Hill and Dee Power are co-founders of Profit Dynamics Inc., a consulting firm that has been helping business owners plan their companies and write their business plans since 1997. They are the authors of “Inside Secrets to Venture Capital,” “Attracting Capital from Angels,” and “The Pocket Small Business Owner’s Guide to Business Plans.”
Their website is www.capital-connection.com.